Medical doctors direct catastrophic injury cross examinations. Cross examination is sometimes exciting, fast, and fun to do and watch. Crossexamining the atfault party following a car accident can be a critical part of a trial. Anyone who learns the rules can become a master of the art of crossexamination. The prosecutors cross examination can be an effective. Witness testifies on direct examination that she saw defendant s car run a red light. Killer cross examination cooperating witness cross.
Cross examination before focusing on impeachment techniques, a brief overview of cross examination in general is in order. Cross examination has many goals, and some goals while applicable to one witness, may be contraindicated for another. The reason door openers are dangerous is because fairness requires that the cross examiner be allowed to explore any topic that was deliberatively introduced on direct. This happens when the party calling the witness does not wish to ask that witness any question themselves, but calls the witness so that heshe can be sworn in and cross examined by the other party if it wishes. Did you love this country in the last week of may, 1917. Medical malpractice crossexamination of defendants expert. During a skilled cross examination, the impact of a prosecution experts testimony can be diminished or completely eliminated. If you select carefully, the expert on cross will have to admit a whole series of good facts for you. Select the goal or goals you intend to achieve during cross examination and stick to questions that achieve those goals, following is a list of potential goals for cross examination. Typical cross examination always covers, the nature of the impact, whether its a lot or a little. This is usually a difficult part of court proceedings for the defense because the arresting officer will likely have much to say that supports the prosecuting attorneys allegations that the defendant was driving while intoxicated.
In fact, if you look at the rules i use for my own cross examination, you will see i attempt to remind myself at every stage not to over embellish my cross examination. Crossexamination of diana simpson maryland personal injury lawyers. Cross examination rules explained by injury attorney. Witness, let us see if there are some things we can agree on. Is there an obligation to put in crossexamination that the. The defendant may blame another person at the scene or a. My own perspective on cross examination has recently broadened. Crossexamining the defendant about other witnesses. But, the courts have to adopt a golden rule that no evidence shall be received against any co om. Cross examination by the defense asks the jury to question what was done procedurally during the stop and arrest, to challenge the validity of scientific tests or to doubt the law enforcement officers competency or even integrity. Attorney help center soup to nuts handling of personal injury cases can you used defendant s guilty plea against him at trial. Attorney hynes has been selected as a top 40 under 40 lawyer by the national trial lawyers.
Police officers, as trained professional witnesses, are often the most difficult. Defendant s counsel then sought to explain the testimony so elicited under cross examination by redirect exami. There are two basic purposes of cross examinations. Who conducts cross examination when the defendant is presenting its case.
The mission of the mock trial board is to encourage and assist thomas m. The purpose of calling somebody on cross examination, is largely to be allowed to question them using leading questions. If an opposition expert isnt likely to say anything that will help you, do a collateral cross. Cross examination, when done correctly, does not have to go on forever. Maryland accident lawyer cross examination maryland. My own perspective on crossexamination has recently broadened. Crossexamination of counsels own witness initially. Interrogatories for proving plaintiffs cause of action. A mountain of evidence was stacked against simpson, but the defense obscured the facts, played with words, and outlawyered the. In refusal cases, the cross examination of the defendant can make or break your case. Pointers for cross examination law firm law offices of. Plan your cross examination in advance to gain concessions from the defendant. Accentuate the positive and watch the dog and ponies introduction. More cross examination information for lawyers and moot court students.
The defendantdriver s defense is that the car he hit was traveling below the speed limit without its lights on. Read full cross examination transcripts from excellent personal injury attorneys compiled by patrick malone in the fearless cross examiner. Sample cross examination cross examination at trial of alleged victims of sexual crimes is an extraordinarily sensitive task. Direct and cross examination of the neurologist direct examination plan. Pay attention during direct examination of defendant s expert. Often, a capable personal injury attorney can expose traffic violations and other evidence of negligence by questioning the atfault motorist. Crossexamination of diana simpson maryland personal. It might turn out, for example, that the defendantdriver has spoken with witnesses to the collision. Sample questions to ask when crossexamining witnesses at a. Plan your crossexamination in advance to gain concessions from the defendant. The plaintiff is john doe, and he is represented by his attorney, jane smith. Home articles 5 cross examination checklists for an auto accident case all partiescomparative fault, plaintiff re injuries, accident reconstruction expert, eyewitnesses and the defense medical expert.
Anyone who learns the rules can become a master of the art of cross examination. Nov 06, 2017 but there is one aspect of the rule which repeatedly attracts criticism when it is not complied with. Part 23 restriction on crossexamination by a defendant contents of this part general rules when this part applies rule 23. For example, assume that our fire engine case one of your witnesses saw the defendant driver at an automobile repair shop just a few days before the accident. Damon is standing outside of the car when the police arrive. Information about crossexamining witnesses if you go to supreme court. Cooley law school students in developing the leadership, civility, and effective advocacy skills necessary to confidently proceed to trial. Following are sample transcripts that include the states direct examination as well the defense attorneys cross examination of state experts. Cross examination of the defense expert begins with his or her direct exam. Cross examination typically is an effort to put a dent into the story thats just been told. How important crossexamination is has been recognized by many courts but perhaps most importantly by the u. Matthew mcconaughey stars in this legal thriller as a lowrent defense attorney named mickey haller. Jan 18, 2016 sample discovery questions mva defendant. Everything you need to know about examination of witnesses.
Limitations on cross examination cross examination is an important part of the right to confront witnesses. I have seen an expert derailed in a few short questions and seen trials turn with a one sentence cross. Direct testimony that opens the door for inquiries on cross examination that otherwise would not be allowed should also be left out. In his main case the plaintiff called the defendant for cross examination under the statute governing examination of the adverse party, elicited certain information, and dismissed the adverse party witness. How to win your dui trial with cross examination 4 most do.
The art of cross examination is one which consumes professional advocates throughout their careers. If the defendant s story, meaning the other driver s story, is that you had the red light, they may ask you about that. And you could not hear the driver say anything, could you. The lincoln lawyer 911 movie clip crossexamination. The goal here is to show that the officer actually does not know whether the charged defendant was driving the vehicle. Without aggressive cross examination by a california defense lawyer experienced in drunk driving cases, the prosecutions expert will only offer testimony that will help convict the driver. Other than what is contained in the police report and other than what was received on the examination for discovery of the plaintiff and other than what is contained in the various medical documentation and other than what is contained in the questions. Crossexamination of diana simpson maryland personal injury. Through preparation of your case, and a basic knowledge of the fundamentals of cross, you can set up a winning summation by scoring points during the cross examination of each witness. It requires not only extensive preparation but also a delicate balance between aggressively discrediting the witness on the one hand and respecting her as a person on the other. Cross examination in an automobile collision or personal. It is important to note that cross examination of a witness by a dwi defense attorney is only allowed to cover matters relevant to the issues in the case.
Think of cross examination as an opportunity to give a closing argument. Character witnesses generally may not be asked hypothetical questions on cross examination. Its another step in taking a thorough depositionin asking the question, you might turn up facts that you did not know before. Having come from the relatively pristine world of criminal law where all that is at stake is the defendant s liberty, i admit that i was initially. Crossexamination of counsels own witness initially examined. When the defendant is called in the plaintiffs case in chief, defendant s counsel will be tempted to do a full direct examination of the defendant as part of the defendant s cross examination. Michigan dui trial drunk driving cross examination. Cross examination has many goals, and some goals while applicable to one. Cross examination is where you get to question the other sides witness. Background investigation first, do a background investigation on the defendant s expert.
Sample crossexamination transcripts criminal defense wiki. Devaluation of the testimony by cross examination is referred to as blank in the field of evidence. When the lawyer for the plaintiff or the government has finished questioning a witness, the lawyer for the defendant may then cross examine the witness. On cross examination, however, it is usually impossible to rehearse, so you will have to rely on meticulous preparation. In cross examination, a defense attorney uses leading questions, which require yes or no responses. Looks like one of the defenses final witnesses wasnt ready to play nice with prosecutor david walgren. If excluding the defendant s biomechanical engineer under daubet is unsuccessful and cross examination of the expert becomes necessary, the following steps may be helpful. Why ask the defendantdriver about casual conversations about the accident or the lawsuit. Sample cross examination new york criminal lawyer zachary.
Cross examination involves relatively straightforward skills. Cross examination is as much an art as it is a science. One of the most critical moments in a car accident personal injury trial is the cross examination of the defendant driver. May 28, 2011 he put on a legal clinic during the oj simpson murder trial in 95. On crossexamination, however, it is usually impossible to rehearse, so you will have to rely on meticulous preparation. Cross examination takes place immediately after direct examination, and is conducted from behind counsel table, or from the podium. Direct cross of defendant s medical doctor expert kevin f hanley, m. Trial advocacy tips crossexamination gain concessions. Limitations on crossexamination overview and discussion. As you will see, youve seen leading questions on cross examination of other witnesses.
Good trial lawyers know how to effectively cross examine witnesses. Cross examination of the defense biomechanical engineer. The arresting officer is typically the key witness for the prosecution in a dwi case. In cross examining a witness, such as the arresting officer, the dwi defense attorney will attempt to discredit, or to weaken in one or more ways, the testimony of the witness.
Next thing that will take plkace in an auto accident trial is cross examination of that witness. Feb 23, 2016 in cross examination, a defense attorney uses leading questions, which require yes or no responses. Cross examination is a dangerous foray behind enemy lines. Read full crossexamination transcripts from excellent personal injury attorneys compiled by patrick malone in the fearless cross examiner. Before conducting the cross examination of an expert witness, the criminal defense attorney must become an expert in forensic evidence as well as the basic principals of forensics. Mar, 2018 here is an excerpt of a cross examination of a cooperating witness in a recent case where i took a particular approach due to the witnesss conduct on direct examination. Crossexamination is a dangerous foray behind enemy lines. The defendant is bob black, and he is represented by his attorney, sharon white. Dont let your mind wander to great avenues of cross examination while the expert is expounding on a point crucial to your case. In refusal cases, the crossexamination of the defendant can make or break your case. Cross examination is very important in the examination of witnesses, due to the cross examination many facts get clear because in the cross examination defendant analyse all the statements of the witnesses then asks cross question related to the statement which was given by the witnesses in the examination in chief. Often, a capable personal injury attorney can expose traffic violations and other evidence of negligence by questioning the atfault motorist i presented cross of the defendant driver at the ttla car wrecks seminar in houston on feb 21, 2019. A number of federal and state courts have ad dressed the question of whether it is permissible for the prosecution to crossexamine a defendant on the stand as to whether or not the defendant believes that the governments witnesses are lying.
Crossexamination takes place after examination inchief, or when a witness is tendered for crossexamination. The presentation of facts by blank does not violate the defendant s right of confrontation, since the defendant has waived his or her right of confrontation of that particular witness, or witnesses, by agreeing to the facts. Cross examination leads driver to admit he acted unreasonably new york attorney jonny kool 212 4061700. Michigan dui trial drunk driving cross examination techniques.
The right to confrontation, however, is not absolute. Mickey haller matthew mcconaughey cross examines charles talbot eric etebari. Simpson was recognized by the missouri bar foundation as the outstanding young trial lawyer in the. Crossexamination of diana simpson defendant driver background. Sample trial materials sample trial transcripts, etc.
There is an obligation to squarely put to a witness in cross examination allegations of dishonesty or, to use a precise synonym, fraud. Listen exceedingly carefully and take concise and legible notes. Exposing a lie by ben rubinowitz and evan torgan often, the objective in cross examination is twofold. In dan hynes dui book to teach other lawyers, he has a chapter on cross examination. Did you say yesterday during direct examination you love a free country.
First, know exactly what your purpose is and structure the examination accordingly. Who conducts crossexamination when the defendant is. Simpson has been litigating personal injury cases, representing both plaintiffs and defendants, since his graduation from the university of missouri at kansas city law school in 1967. This is because, although cross examination is important, it is just one aspect of a multipart trial. The ability to lead ones client through his or her direct testimony is generally too tempting to pass up. Katzmanns cross examination of sacco began in a similar fashion, and continued to include lengthy exchanges in which katzmann challenged sacco to defend his political views. Making the defendant testify in the plaintiffs casein. Cross examination is generally limited to questioning only on matters that were raised during direct examination. He has tried more than 200 jury trials and has been a frequent speaker at cle seminars. On cross examination, defense counsel asks witness, didnt you tell a police officer on a prior occasion that the light was yellow when defendant drove through. Cross examination questioning the evidence provided by the arresting officer. To improve your chances of success, dont focus solely on impeaching the defendant. Obviously on crossexamination during an auto accident trial the main.
It is without question that the crime of driving under the influence is given a great deal of attention by the legislature, courts, media and public in general, year in and year out. On direct examination, witnesses are controlled through preparation and rehearsal. The witness indicated in her statement that the defendant was advised that his brakes were in poor repair, but that he left without having them fixed. Leading questions may be asked during cross examination. Cross examination leads driver to admit he acted unreasonably.
1246 177 1048 112 1069 139 1026 16 1293 948 947 400 455 660 972 52 829 878 669 1006 1399 1058 1055 423 275 421 1210 215 1267 867 1376 662 1115 413 172 605